|
Tough battle to vote on, hence why I have avoided the thread till now...Topic was very vague which doesn't help...
Calibrizzle - Laid the foundations / save our nations doesn't match up as a rhyme, maybe you meant saving our nations  [/pedanticism]...also, Obama isn't a Muslim so you lose points for that sir (I made same mistake before, and suppose you could say its the security guard thinking/saying that)...and I read apparently Muslims are more free to practice their faith in USA than in Europe, US society generally more accepting of different faiths (peep The Economist)...I liked what you put down a lot after that, obviously slick rhymes and on point content...until it got to the JFK part I thought you had smashed it, but I wasn't sure if you meant that he "experienced" it as a security guard or as a youth or whatever...coz if he was guarding JFK then there is no way he would be guarding Obama...nearly 40years later, and again, vest is irrelevant? JFK was shot so it would be relevant  ...I guess maybe you meant like sniper rifle, or maybe you did it coz it was a sick rhyme...next two lines were nice...closer was ok, bit of a bland way to end but then the topic doesn't really give you much scope for a sick ending...so it was coolio I guess...I liked that you told the story in first person with a smooth rhyme structure and rhythm, so I can forgive you a couple of 'factual' errors/queries
Free Da Fizzle Dizzle - Liked how you went first person with it as well, you tried to flip the topic in a unique way but I didn't really like it...I don't think secret service agents have those kinds of opinions as they are screened heavily and don't 'do it for cheques', and I don't think you are gonna have an agent that is racist/hates the president enough to want to kill him...think you probably overthought the topic to make it too 'clever'...you also had a factual error like Calibrizzle..."offered and asked", president doesn't chose his security detail, that was kind of in between Muslim/JFK for me...in terms of the verse you know your style is sick, intense rhyme structure with fluid flows as well as impressively descriptive content and expression..."feeling fear like the coolness of wind"..."one could discharge, a gun and run, from the puppets we are" << ridiculous
The reason why it's tough to vote...because I loved Freeda's style & expression within that, but I think his take on the topic itself i.e. the 'story' behind it was weak & unrealistic...so while you can pick out a line and shake your head in disbelief at how well it was written the main aspect of the verse was missing...did he write a better "verse" in terms of style & lyrical content than Calibra, unquestionably...but it being unrealistic in its main underpinnings spoils it for me...Calibra had some cute references in there that improved his verse, and his story wasn't really as advanced as Freedas...like you can follow Freeda's story a bit more closely because of his detail...even if I think it isn't real...I'm struggling to balance the strengths and weaknesses I see here, so difficult to quantify...in terms of verse vs. verse I think Freeda wrote a better one...but loses points for the credibility, it would have been a bit easier for me if Calibra had written a verse to his full capacity, because he lost a couple of points for the muslim reference, but it wasn't crucial to his verse like the story was to Freeda's...so since I am here to pick somebody I'm going to go for Calibra, when you write a topical you need to convince me of the story and make it compelling...doesn't matter how well it is written if you don't have the first and foremost...
Vote = Calibra
I hate you both, you bastards
-------------
|